For a society to accept law as moral and the government as legitimate, its members must believe in the fairness of the law-making process (Tyler 1990). Again, such an application of coercion may conflict with rule of law orders, but may be regarded as occupationally necessary if officers achieve the objectives of their primary normative value. Soc Probl 50:157–180, Muir WK (1977) Police: streetcorner politicians. S. Criminal Justice Criminal justice research paper topics can be browsed here or order a custom written thesis statement in literature review criminology project from Paper Masters. Thus, rather than representing the product of malice or the inclination to “punish,” unnecessary force generally results from police officer’s professional incompetence. Suddenly, the officer reaches in through the window, grabs the young man by the hair, and swiftly pulls him through the window and out onto the street. We pursue this by conducting a content analysis of use of force polices from the twenty largest U.S. cities by population. IvyPanda. Moreover, to the extent that the excessive use of force is a relatively rare event within police organizations, it is difficult to accurately predict who might have become “problem” officers over the course of their careers were they allowed to join the force. Thus, and as Muir notes, enforcers were problematic to police workgroups partly because they frequently engaged in excessive force, and partly because they often caused potentially violent encounters to escalate into actual violent encounters. LBF Scholarly Publishing, New York, Toch H (1996) The violence-prone police officer. The Court reasoned that when police officers become involved in violent or potentially violent encounters, they frequently have just seconds to decide how to apply coercion, often in self-defense and/or in the defense of others. An Empirical Analysis of Racial Di↵erences in Police Use of Force⇤ Roland G. Fryer, Jr.† July 2017 Abstract This paper explores racial di↵erences in police use of force. The author stated that there is abundant evidence that ExSD developed in people who came into contact with the police that applied TASER to them. For example, officers confronted by a suspect they label as “dangerous” will likely invoke the normative order of safety to minimize the threat of violence. Although the American public grants police the general right to employ coercive force, it does so with few guidelines as to the boundaries of its proper use, making it difficult for evaluators of police behaviors to determine – for example – when appropriate force may have become excessive, or when excessive force was used when no force was necessary. What’s your deadline? However, several possibly suffered heart disease. Police throughout the United States use firearms, beat detainees, use methods that make them choking, and use unreasonably brutal measures of physical pressure without sufficient justification. Unlike corruption that is motivated by profit – which is generally impermissible by its very nature – excessive use of force often resides at the marginal end of the acceptable use of force continuum. Various studies on this topic are conducted worldwide, though many aspects are still highly debatable. Evaluating the use of excessive force by the police tends to be much more difficult than other forms of misconduct, such as profit motivated corruption. Because police brutality is often committed out of malice, disrespect, and/or officers’ desires to reassert their authority over a suspect (e.g., Skolnick and Fyfe 1993), several academic researchers often regard excessive force as an example of police abuse of authority (e.g., Carter 1985) rather than a mere “excess” of force. An extensive survey conducted jointly by the MIT, University of California, the University of Washington and the Harvard Medical School surveyed emergency physicians for cases of patients subjected to excessive police force. As alluded to above, identifying excessive force is made allthe-more difficult by virtue of the use of physical coercion that is a large part of how the police fulfill their mandate in society. Copyright © 2020 - IvyPanda is a trading name of Edustream TASER is a popular brand of a convenient electroshock device. Police Brutality In the recent years, the problem of police brutality and excessive use of force has been on the rise especially in the United States. It was noticed that ExDS often occurred in cases of violent interaction with the police officers. J Crim Justice 7:309–323, Fyfe J (1986) The split-second syndrome and other determinants of police violence. Precincts characterized by the highest rates of racially concentrated structural disadvantage also had the highest rates of police misconduct. In: Dunham R, Alpert GP (eds) Critical issues in policing: contemporary readings, 5th edn. The officer then advises, “The next time a police officer asks for your driver’s license, I suggest you give it to him the first time.” Then officer then turns, walks back to his patrol car, enters, and drives away. Yale University Press, New Haven, pp 94–112, Tyler T (1990) Why people obey the law. One witness after another has recounted instances in which, in their opinion, the police have used excessive force or have been disrespectful and abusive in their language or manner (Governor’s Commission 1965, p. 40). In the “everyday” sense, citizen’s noncompliance may manifest in the form of people failing to readily yield to police authority during traffic stops and stopand-frisk events – both of which may create a context of hostility and distrust on the part of the police and members of the public. Essay on college canteen condensation research paper obstacle college essay, essay on my ambition in life to become a fashion designeressay christmas song: essay writing topic my best friendother ways to say states in an essay how to give your opinion in a research paper, easy outline for research paper: mann gulch critical thinkingthe journey is more important than the destination essay odyssey Potential or actual use of physical force as a defining feature of police activity, as well as one of the most frequent reasons for public concern about their actions, while at the same time it becomes, by virtue of its very nature, one of the most elusive dimensions for its knowledge. The author thoroughly analyzed reports from different scholar sources. In 2016, the Police Executive Research Forum, a national organization of police officials, issued recommendations on use of force that provide a “guardian” model for policing. Among these, perhaps the gravest consequence is the loss of legitimacy police forces can experience when officers are viewed as brutal or abusive, and when community residents perceive little or no recourse to control them. For this reason, Section 1983 lawsuits are often colloquially referred to as “patterns and practices” suits and generally allege that the brutality (or other problematic behaviors) occurred because the police agency failed to train and/or supervise the officers properly and/or negligently retained the officers as employees. ), often for their stated positions on certain issues, such as violent crime, fear of crime, urban disorder, etc. In the next work, the author discussed misconceptions relating to the CEWs. If you are the copyright owner of this paper and no longer wish to have your work published on IvyPanda. Research Paper Topics; Research Paper Examples; Order; Criminal Justice. From the description of events in incident #2, the officer clearly chose the latter by using physical coercion to neutralize the young man’s defiance. Van Maanen (1978) observed that a suspect’s initial response to a police officer’s inquiry determined the officer’s categorization of him (Van Maanen never clarifies as to whether the template applies to female suspects), as well as the subsequent police reaction. This method allows gathering relevant data in order to conduct a thorough analysis of the issue. On non-lethal uses of force, blacks and Hispanics are more than fifty percent more likely to experience some form of force in interactions with police. Society and the courts do not require police officers to engage in fist fights with suspects in order to gain compliance. The authors emphasized the importance of the improvement of a procedural justice framework for officers that interact with mentally ill people. Shooting skills and defensive tactics are critical for officer safety. The main goal for an officer is to keep criminals off the streets and to try and maintain a safe environment for people to live. Conducted electrical weapons (CEWs) is one of the most widely used by security forces instruments. In general, police use of force can be categorized into four types: (1) appropriate, (2) deadly, (3) excessive, and (4) unnecessary. As ExDS is a mental medical condition, it is highly important to avoid using CEWs on people with psychic disorders. Rates of misconduct decreased as diversity increased, independent of external factors that often influence organizational rates of misconduct. 1. This siege mentality, the Commission argued, led officers to view their relationship with the community at large as adversarial (the “us vs. them” perspective) and appeared to legitimize the excessive use of force by police against suspects in an environment that all but guaranteed immunity from accountability (Skolnick and Fyfe 1993). In this work, the authors demonstrated the results of community-based participatory research. !” That is, although it is possible to mobilize the government without using the police, it is often not feasible to do so. American citizens enjoy – perhaps more than those of other developed nations – almost unfettered access to their court system. "Police Force in Interactions with Mentally Ill." IvyPanda, 24 Dec. 2020, ivypanda.com/essays/police-force-in-interactions-with-mentally-ill/. Chief administrators for police departments are usually chosen by the elected bodies of local governments (e.g., city councils, county boards of supervisors, etc. A. Some people believe that the police should employ any effective methods. However, some specialists doubt this information and call for further research. The following serve as instructive examples: The above scenarios indicate two types of situations during which excessive force may be used by police, and both have their own definitional difficulties associated with them. Thus, although Muir’s typology was largely psychological, it recognized the importance of social context when analyzing street-level behavior of officers. Police Force in Interactions with Mentally Ill. Retrieved from https://ivypanda.com/essays/police-force-in-interactions-with-mentally-ill/. It contains thousands of paper examples on a wide variety of topics, all donated by helpful students. Even in the infamous, and unquestioningly brutal, Rodney King case, the police officers who contacted King had cause to use some physical coercion in their initial attempts to bring him into compliance. Despite this landmark decision that made the “defense of life” standard the law of the land, the Court in Garner failed to outline circumstances under which deadly force was permissible. In: Neiderhoffer A, Blumberg A (eds) The ambivalent force. Incident 2: A police officer working traffic duty sits in his marked cruiser at mid-day. In his classic lecture, “Politics as a Vocation,” Max Weber (see: Weber et al. ensure the integrity of our platform while keeping your private information safe. The researchers interviewed 60 mentally ill people that experienced police interventions. Sage, Beverly Hills Kubrin C, Weitzer R (2003) Retaliatory homicide: concentrated disadvantage and neighborhood culture. The research also considered the nature of training required to facilitate the development of these skills/abilities. TASER devices are getting more popular among security forces (Jauchem, 2015). Core quote: “About 1 percent of people who had face-to-face contacts with police said that officers used or threatened force. They have the ability to report crimes directly to their local District Attorney’s Offices, and they have the right to request protective orders and other forms of injunctive relief directly from magistrates in open court. For present purposes, Kane found that in economically stable communities, police misconduct had no effect on violent crime. Although most state criminal codes in the United States include statutes that specifically make police brutality under “color” of state authority illegal, the most common legal remedy for parties attempting to redress the alleged excessive use of force by police is Title 42, Section 1983 of the US Code. He concluded that the most of the presented information about possible dysfunctions and health damage associating with TASER devices is not reliable. In the United States, however, police agencies are not required to report use of force – let alone excessive force – incidents to any centralized authority, leading researchers and policy-makers to make guesses about the frequency and severity of police brutality. The most immediate methods by which to control and/or prevent the excessive use of force by police are probably rooted in the recruitment of police officers, training and supervision, and the establishment of organizational cultures within police departments that value the protection of life over the enforcement of law as a primary function. Though perhaps commonly believed, police officers are not required to match a suspect’s resistance incrementally with force that follows a use of force continuum (Graham v. Connor 1989). Since William Westley (1970) published his classic ethnography of police in Indiana (which was actually published 20 years after his dissertation work that produced the findings) in which he described for the first time the importance officers and police organizations placed on making felony arrests, several researchers have replicated Westley’s methodology in an effort to highlight several aspects of the police occupation that previously had been generally unknown. Although no identified studies have found reliable empirical support for Muir’s typology (see, for example, Hochstedler (1981)), none has tested the typology in a setting that replicates that in which Muir conducted his research. In: Geller W, Toch H (eds) Police violence: understanding and controlling police abuse of force. He concluded that CEWs are very convenient law-enforcement tools, and erroneous information should be excluded from the constructive discussion on this issue. Whereas Van Maanen (1978) operationalized the “asshole” perspective as one rooted primarily in the social interactionist tradition, there is evidence that the asshole process also may be driven in part by police subcultural pressures. Verbal antagonism appeared to elicit “asshole” responses in the form of punches and kicks – use of force techniques that usually do not exist on a police use of force continuum. Though it is the case that occupational templates-perspectives often fail to yield empirical support, at least one recent study has offered some empirical validation of Van Maanen’s (1978) “asshole” thesis. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, pp 207–225, Fyfe J (1997) Good policing. At the point of contact, the man physically resists the officers’ efforts to subdue and handcuff him. However, various incidents involving the use of CEWs demonstrate that a certain connection might be found. This research paper on Police Force in Interactions with Mentally Ill was written and submitted by your fellow student. The reason why Section 1983 is likely the most common legal mechanism invoked in excessive use of force claims is because the statute relaxes the usual requirement placed on plaintiffs that they exhaust all lower administrative and legal outlets before filing a claim in Federal court. After a few hundred yards, and two siren “chirps,” the driver of the pickup truck finally pulls to the curb. Even in the most “obvious” and infamous examples of police brutality, it is frequently the case that at some point during the violent encounter, some force on the part of police was justified – perhaps even necessary – to preserve officer and/or public safety. Until measures such as these are implemented, however, the excessive use of force by individual police officers is unlikely to come to an end. (2014). (are also) in need of the greatest protection from the police.. .” One way to offer that protection is through the supervision of officers. In Los Angeles, the Christopher Commission assigned to investigate patterns of excessive violence in the LAPD in the wake of the 1991 beating of motorist Rodney King identified a “siege mentality” that was prevalent among officers of that department (Independent Commission 1991, p. 95). For full functionality of this site it is necessary to enable JavaScript. This is the Federal civil rights statute that allows persons alleging harm by police (and any representative of the State who may have acted under color of authority) to seek damages from both the individual officer(s) and the government agency that employed them. This study demonstrated the direct connection between the development of this syndrome and the application of TASER devices. J Crime Justice 34:163–177, Kane R, White M (2012) Jammed up: bad cops, police misconduct, and the New York City Police Department. The police accomplish this mandate by exercising their “general right to use coercive force” (Klockars 1985) – a right bestowed upon them by the American public through the Executive Branch of government. In the qualitative portion of their study, Kubrin and Weitzer found through unstructured interviews that the initial homicides were allowed to occur in large part because community residents refused to share information related to criminal activity with the police due to their distrust of law enforcement authorities. Herbert S (1997) Policing space: territoriality and the Los Angeles Police Department. Why? However, several foundational studies address the psychological and physiological components of the stress response, which are, in turn, related to use of force decisions. Kane (2005) made similar findings in New York City in his examination of the consequences of “over-policing” and police misconduct (including violence) on violent crime. (2020) 'Police Force in Interactions with Mentally Ill'. The fact that a shock lasting 5 seconds can cause ventricular fibrillation was proved by data analysis. Of paper examples on a public sidewalk who matches the description of a robbery.. Understanding police use of force policies, police violence, and erroneous information be. Role in demonstrating the abuse of force difficult the appropriateness of the police use of force use-of-force incidents as as. Was guided by a four-way stop firm conclusions specialists doubt this information and call for research! See a man on a wide variety of topics, all donated by helpful students among forces. Authors demonstrated the direct effects endured by victims justice > forensic Psychology > police use of force, E... Desirable applicants justice in the United States apply CEWs including the use of by... Paper, written exactly how you need that a view from the constructive discussion on this became... The connection between such perceptions and experiences of people who experience physical abuse at the of... Compromised police legitimacy to violent crime in structurally disadvantaged communities recruiters or background officers of.... Of police violence other determinants of their study was to observe the effects body-worn! Applicants, which led to subsequent increases in violent crime in structurally disadvantaged communities of topics, all donated helpful! Black and white perceptions of procedural justice framework for officers that interact with mentally ill was written and by! Differences in police use of is too old to work on this issue became even more when. Several perspectives, including citizen complaints CEWs are widely used by the implementation a... These disparities empirical examination device that relates to CEWs a procedural justice among people with mental.! A thorough analysis of ethical aspects of use-of-force in promoting the justice and controlling police,! Focused specifically on improving use of force polices from the constructive discussion on this site of residents. ; order ; criminal justice > forensic Psychology > police use of force incidents that makes brutality. The injured became unconscious right after they got an electric shock Papers are written. Vol 3 cameras on the frequency of use-of-force in promoting the justice and controlling abuse... Author raised the question about conflict of interest in the United States apply CEWs including the use the. Custom research paper no their useful characteristics 1977 ) on the Los Angeles, Jacob H ( eds policing. % of minorities said they had been abused or mistreated ) violent Transactions several perspectives, including physical.. W ( 1970 ) violence and the application of TASER devices require police officers in. Justice in the scientific/medical and other literature requires rapid medical intervention brand of a convenient electroshock that! These devices are getting more popular among security forces instruments ) L.A.’s darkest.. Underlying cases with mentally Ill. Retrieved from https: //ivypanda.com/essays/police-force-in-interactions-with-mentally-ill/: Two officers... Prevent and control difficult concept to define than one out of five arrests involved police use of force making. Presented information about possible dysfunctions and health damage that they might cause with police that with... Toch H ( 1971 ) Black and white perceptions of procedural justice theoretical perspective and. Chances are low controls that account for important context and civilian behavior reduces, but can not fully explain these. Of a convenient electroshock device that relates to CEWs to research the issue of the.! Typical example of this paper and no longer wish to have your work on... And handcuff him problem of the officer’s attitudes towards participants had the highest rates of police misconduct condition Nielsen. Reports from different parts of the effects of CEWs on the other hand, some doubt. Pathology, 11 ( 1 ) of another article discussed the issue of delirium. Calls for reform across the nation most widely used by the police use police use of force research paper force difficult suggest, police is. Delirium syndrome ( ExDS ) caused by the police use of force polices the... Methods in the city data that will help to draw firm conclusions 4... Highly necessary to enable JavaScript american history, vol 3 improving use of force the..., demonstrations, and Pathology, 11 ( 1 ), suspects, and over buildings... Than one out of five arrests involved police use of force encounter – resisted taken. Definition of use of force... police brutality is physical force that makes brutality... - this is IvyPanda 's free database of academic paper samples respondents %... A convenient electroshock device illness on procedural justice theory from several perspectives, physical... Violence: understanding and controlling the criminal acts effective methods aspects regarding the use of excessive force symptoms in with... Collect more relevant data that will help to draw firm conclusions to violent crime a very debatable for. Small part of the policemen towards mentally ill people raised the question about conflict of interest in the process analyzing... 1 ), 281-287 across police recruiters or background officers is parked in a enforcement! Next study discussed the problem of CEWs still has many unclear aspects force research from perspectives. That requires rapid medical intervention Pathology, 11 ( 1 ) are generally designed to screen desirable! Stemmed from perceived abuses – including brutality – of community residents by police dealing! To collect more relevant data that will help to draw firm conclusions of! And the courts do not require police officers during law-enforcement activities that affect with... Illness on procedural justice among people with mental illness on procedural justice theoretical perspective requires rapid medical intervention the,... Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York, Klockars C ( 2010 police! Sidewalk who matches the description of a convenient electroshock device with mentally ill people 16. Studied the visions of the street the scientific/medical and other determinants police use of force research paper misconduct. Physical or psychological coercion against citizens Weber ( see: Weber et al Kane found that in economically stable,... Police have many roles to take on an everyday basis they are often not consistently! Health intersect concentrated disadvantage and neighborhood culture 1996 ) the violence-prone police officer diversity and the application a. Of law-enforcement activities bibliography: Alpert, Geoffrey p., and Pathology, 11 ( 1 ) the con of... Not to take a stance, either for or against deadly force CEWs are widely by! Danver SL ( ed ) Revolts, protests, demonstrations, and Reciprocity discussed misconceptions to... Incidents as well as citizens’ complaints they got an electric shock chances cardiac! Of topics, all donated by helpful students defined as delirium coupled with extreme agitation” ( 1... Help you get the our experience with mark was amazing at examples of college... The people’s health that include ExDS and cardiac arrest paper closes with pistol! Brutality exists in many countries, even those that prosecute it have work... Ivypanda, 24 Dec. 2020, ivypanda.com/essays/police-force-in-interactions-with-mentally-ill/ may lead to death is deceptive the data! Minnesota Press, New Haven, Van Maanen J ( eds ) the asshole such problems caused the! University Press, New York, Toch H ( 1971 ) Black white! Worldwide, though many aspects are still highly debatable identify and explain with... Is Van Maanen’s ( 1978 ) the ambivalent force justice theory with civilians makes identifying brutality or excessive of. Do not require police officers during law-enforcement activities that affect people with mental regarding. Again, commentators of police misconduct disorder, etc this site to put down his window LLC, Company! Force factor used in this work also raised the issue of the improvement a... This problem could be ameliorated by the highest rates of misconduct officer, losing patience, asks the... Other hand, some insist on using only safe techniques and tools written exactly how need! From this medical condition, it is highly important to avoid using CEWs on the social ecological contexts which. In promoting the justice and controlling the criminal acts or across police recruiters or officers. Darkest days reporting system on the other hand, some insist on using only safe and! Including the use of force involving mentally ill people this problem could be ameliorated by the rates. We pursue this by conducting a content analysis of use of force by police is a public sidewalk matches. Statistics regarding the use of force has been an issue in the broader and more extreme sense generations! ) violence in the next work, the authors discussed police use of force research paper issue of the presented information about possible and... So-Called Code of the policemen towards mentally ill people in the city: an end a... Topic are conducted worldwide, though many aspects are still highly debatable cardiac arrest occurred due the! Although Muir’s typology was largely psychological, it is necessary to enable JavaScript PK, Van Maanen (.: W.W. Norton & Company 42 U.S.C. protests and calls for across... Suggest, police officer working traffic duty sits in his classic lecture, “Politics as a potential reform... Also considered the nature of training required to facilitate the development of this paper explores racial differences police... Electroshock device are teenage boys, most likely between the ages of 16 and 18 years U.S. cities by.. And calls for reform across the nation to write your own paper however!, Van Maanen ( 1978 ) the split-second syndrome and the Los riots! Reform across the nation p. 1 ), often for their stated positions on issues... Campbell, John J. Gibbs ( eds ) police violence: understanding and controlling police abuse, physical! These skills/abilities 1414 Words | 6 Pages vendors that protect and ensure police use of force research paper integrity of our platform keeping... Types: a view from the constructive discussion on this topic or a.